Well,
if you're an average
working American
with no kids in
college and not
looking to buy a new
home or car, the
answer is about
$1,000 over the next
two years. Double
that if you're
married and you and
your spouse work;
shrink it to $300 if
you are retired or
disabled. And get
out your calculator
if you are
unemployed.
It's not a lot of
money to cheer
about, but then
again, you set aside
$500 for every
working American,
and the figure for
tax relief is going
to start around $140
billion right there;
the sheer size of
the project dictates
that getting a few
thousand bucks per
family would be too
much to handle. And
anyway, the stimulus
bill's main focus is
shoring up the
economy through job
creation and aid to
states.
Still, there are
some tax provisions
in each of the House
and Senate versions
of the stimulus plan
that may benefit
you. "There are a
lot of little things
covered from a tax
standpoint," said
Mel Schwarz,
director of tax
legislative affairs
at Grant Thornton in
Washington, D.C.
"Most people will
probably get one of
them, some will get
one or two and then
a small group will
be affected by a
number of them ...
it's all about your
individual
circumstances."
Of course,
businesses benefit,
too. For instance,
both the House and
Senate plans include
a "net operating
loss carry-back" tax
break that allows
companies to use
existing losses to
offset taxes paid on
profits in the
previous five years,
up from the current
two years now.
"This is a
tremendous amount of
cash that [business
taxpayers] can get
simply by filing
returns or adjusting
withholding," said
Clint Stretch,
managing principal
of tax policy at
Deloitte Tax. (The
House version lets
firms use up to 90%
of their losses
while the Senate
version allows for
100% of losses.)
Keep in mind that
most of the tax
breaks are
short-term, lasting
only a year or two.
And stay tuned for
any changes in the
final law --
Congress aims to
send a bill to the
president by Monday.
Here
are some of the key
tax provisions for
individual
taxpayers:
Both the House and
Senate bills include
a new refundable tax
credit of up to $500
for working
individuals and
$1,000 for working
families for 2009
and 2010.
Whether you're
eligible may well
depend on how
lawmakers meld the
two bills: In the
House version this
break starts to
phase out when
adjusted gross
income reaches
$75,000 for single
and
head-of-household
filers and $150,000
for
married-filing-jointly
filers.
But fewer people
qualify under the
Senate's bill: The
phase-out starts at
$70,000 for single
filers and $140,000
for joint filers.
The alternative
minimum tax needs
fixing by Congress.
Without a temporary
"patch," millions of
taxpayers would fall
into AMT
eligibility, costing
them many thousands
in additional taxes.
But every year,
Congress enacts a
law raising the
exemption amounts
for one year,
ensuring that fewer
people have to pay
the AMT. The Senate
stimulus plan shells
out the $70 billion
(i.e., in lost
revenue) necessary
to protect a good
chunk of taxpayers
again this year.
That's not a part of
the House plan, but
either way it's
all-but-certain
Congress will pass
another AMT patch
later this year.
"I think it's there
to get Republican
votes" for the
stimulus bill, said
Mark Luscombe, a
principal analyst
with CCH Inc., a
Riverwoods, Ill.,
tax publisher. "They
wanted to increase
the tax breaks and
that's one everyone
could say 'we're
going to do it
anyway, so we'll do
it now.'"
If you are among the
millions who would
face "alt-min"
without the fix,
this is a big deal.
But you were going
to get this relief
anyway, with or
without a stimulus.
Economic recovery
payments
This one-time
payment of $300 for
retirees, disabled
individuals, Social
Security
beneficiaries, SSI
recipients and
veterans receiving
veterans' disability
compensation and
pension benefits is
in the Senate bill
but not the House
bill, so it's
unclear whether it
will make it into
final law.
Don't confuse this
with the "recovery
rebate credit" which
taxpayers, on their
2008 return, can
claim if they may
now qualify for last
year's economic
stimulus payment.
Expanded education
tax credit
Another change
proposed in both
bills for the next
two years makes the
Hope credit worth up
to $2,500 and good
for four years of
college costs
(instead of the
current limit of
two).
The credit phases
out when adjusted
gross income hits
$80,000 for single
filers or $160,000
for joint filers.
That means more
people are eligible:
Under current law,
the Hope credit
phase-out in 2009
starts at $50,000
for single filers
and $100,000 for
married filers, said
Bob Scharin, senior
tax analyst from the
tax and accounting
business of Thomson
Reuters. "This is
significantly
higher," he said.
His colleague
agreed. "This will
help a lot of people
with kids in
college, and this
might be the kind of
provision that they
eventually make
permanent," said Jim
Seidel, director of
federal tax content
for the tax and
accounting business
of Thomson Reuters.
"But, again, this is
something that
depends on your
circumstances. If
your kids have
already been to
college or aren't
going for a few more
years, this isn't
going to help you
now."
The versions vary
greatly between the
House and Senate,
but if you are in
the market for a new
house (or bought one
since the start of
this year), there is
real help to be had
here. The House bill
eliminates the
repayment
requirement for the
up-to-$7,500
refundable
first-time
home-buyer credit,
unless the home is
flipped within 36
months of purchase.
By comparison, the
Senate would provide
a one-time 10% tax
credit up to $15,000
on the purchase of a
principal residence.
That credit can be
used over two tax
years (making it
worth more to
low-income taxpayers
who could never use
a $15,000 credit in
a single year) and
is not recaptured
provided that the
home is owned for at
least 24 months. The
Senate's credit is
for a home purchased
within one year from
the date the
stimulus bill
becomes law. Stay
tuned for the final
details on this law.
Breaks for new car
buyers
The Senate bill
creates a deduction
for interest paid on
car loans and state
sales taxes paid on
new car and light
truck purchases. The
interest can be on
debt of up to
$49,500 for cars
purchased after Nov.
12, 2008 and before
the start of 2010.
If you are in the
market for a new
car, this might be a
great deal, but with
manufacturers like
GM pushing 0%
financing deals, you
actually may have to
take a lesser
financial package to
get the tax savings.
Expanded earned
income tax credit
This one sounds
great, but it's
nothing to shout
about when you do
the math. Both the
House and Senate
temporarily increase
the earned income
tax credit to 45% of
the family's first
$12,570 of earned
income for families
with three or more
children. They also
make this credit
available to more
people by,
generally, raising
threshold levels.
"The actual dollars
in the pocket here
will not be huge,"
Luscombe said. "You
get 5% of an
additional couple of
thousand dollars, so
it would be a few
hundred bucks if it
applies to you."
Still, for a
lower-income family,
that's not bad news.
Expanded child tax
credit
If you have
dependent children,
both bills increase
the eligibility for
the refundable child
tax credit in 2009
and 2010, but the
House is more
generous than the
Senate, as it
eliminates the floor
at which this credit
starts, while the
Senate just lowers
it to $8,100 from
$8,500 now.
Here's how it works:
Right now, the tax
credit starts to
take effect when you
have $8,500 in
earnings or more;
you get 15% of your
earnings up to a
limit of $2,000. The
House bill allows
the credit to start
phasing in at $1 of
income; the Senate
bill at $8,100.
The House's version,
which targets the
provision to
lower-income
taxpayers, is a good
way to stimulate the
economy, said Len
Burman, director of
the Tax Policy
Center, a joint
venture of the Urban
Institute and
Brookings
Institution in
Washington. "If you
give $2,000 to
someone earning
$13,000, they pretty
much have to spend
it because they're
living on the edge.
If they're earning
$100,000 they're
more likely to bank
the money," he said.
Andrea Coombes is
an assistant
personal finance
editor for
MarketWatch, based
in San Francisco.
Chuck Jaffe is a
senior MarketWatch
columnist. His work
appears in dozens of
U.S. newspapers.